Click here for special movie and show lists

5 Sinister Shows Like American Horror Story

Starring: Jessica Lange, Kathy Bates, Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters

American Horror Story is not for the faint of heart, with enough blood and gore to make any horror buff happy. Each season of this show is a new story and many actors return the next season as a new character.

6 years in, and the series has had a murder house, an asylum set in 1964, a war between witches and their enemies, a 1952 freak show, a supernatural hotel set in 2015, and a crew that tries to document the mysteries of Roanoke.

If you want a lot more blood then click on these other shows like American Horror Story and we’ve provided all the links if you’re wondering where to buy tv shows. Happy watching.

Scream Queens

Starring: Jamie Lee Curtis, Emma Roberts, Lea Michele and Abigail Breslin

One of the most anticipated series like American Horror Story is Scream Queens. The queen of horror herself, Jamie Lee Curtis, is the dean of Wallace University, where fraternity and sorority students are being murdered by the school mascot called the Red Devil.

In Scream Queens, each massacre is unique, bloody, over-done and extremely brilliant. Comedic horror is the root of this addition to American Horror Story show recommendations and it knows how to succeed.

You’ve never seen someone as vile and self-centered as Chanel Oberlin who is the leader of the ‘Chanels’ and the head of Kappa Kappa Tau.

back to menu ↑

Bates Motel

Starring: Vera Farmiga and Freddie Highmore

You can find Bates Motel on Amazon, one of the best places to purchase tv shows online. Another one of the best shows like American Horror Story is Bates Motel. Bates Motel is a prequel to the movie ‘’Psycho’’ by Alfred Hitchcock. This story tells us what happened before Norman Bates and his mother buys the hotel and all the events that happen after. If you’re looking for something that will raise the hair on your arms, then don’t wait and click on this addition to shows similar to American Horror Story immediately!!

back to menu ↑

Penny Dreadful

Starring: Josh Hartnett, Timothy Dalton, and Eva Green

One of the darkest additions to American Horror Story show suggestions is Penny Dreadful. Let’s travel back in time to Victorian London for this one. This psychological thriller is suspenseful, scary and very dark. Famous monsters like Dorian Gray, Dr.Frankenstein and Dracula are hiding in every dark damp corner of the London streets, but the real demons are the ones the main characters have to fight with internally.

Penny Dreadful is one of those creepiest shows like American Horror Story that will haunt your dreams.

back to menu ↑

True Blood

Starring: Anna Paquin, Stephen Moyer, and Alexander Skarsgard

Price: $19.96
Was: $24.99

True Blood is one of the best American Horror Story show alternatives that is based on the Sookie Stackhouse novels by Charlaine Harris. Sookie is from a southern town called Bon Temps, where she works at a bar called Merlotte’s. One night during her shift she meets a strange man named Bill. She later discovers that he is a vampire and supernatural beings are real. Her life from that moment on has been changed forever.

If you’re looking for lots of blood, and some very sexy scenes, watch this great story in shows like American Horror Story, now!

back to menu ↑

Fear Itself

Starring: Victoria Pratt, Johnathon Schaech, Anna Kendrick and Cory Monteith

Lastly, we must add Fear Itself to American Horror Story show recommendations. The only thing we have to fear is fear itself — Franklin D. Roosevelt Fear itself does what it says, it brings the fear out of you. Each episode is a new standalone story made to terrify you and usually ends with a twist ending. Think super scary, made for adults episodes like Goosebumps for children.

If you never saw this show and love scary stuff, click on this horrific addition to series like American Horror Story right away, you won’t regret it unless you’re too scared! Find this old tv series on DVD and instant video by following the link provided.

*** This show is also called Masters of Horror.

More Movies Like