Click here for special movie and show lists

7 “One Giant Mystery” Shows Like The OA

Starring: Brit Marling, Jason Isaacs, Scott Wilson

Watch on Netflix

Some of the best tv shows are those that hold one giant mystery in their grasps. Each episode gives you more pieces to the puzzle and the season finale usually ends with a massive reveal that leaves you awestruck. This list of mystery tv shows is guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat from beginning to end. These mystery tv series are exciting, dramatic, captivating, and when the finale storyline is unveiled, your mind will be blown. One of the best mystery series of the year is the OA.

The OA is a Netflix original that people are talking about around the world. This Netflix mystery series is about an inexplicable reappearance and the twists and turns that come with it. Prairie Johnson was blind when she disappeared 7 years ago. Now, as a young woman, Prairie is back and her eyesight is too. Some people think that Prairie is a miracle, while others think that she could be dangerous to society. To understand the mystery of the OA show, you have to watch it from the beginning.

The OA characters bring the show to life with their outstanding performances and the more you watch, the more you will realize that life isn’t always what it seems. The OA tv series can’t be explained in just a few words and it’s best for you to watch it without any spoilers. Don’t miss the OA season finale to understand how all the pieces fit together. The OA is a tv series unto itself, there aren’t a lot like it, but if you like the one giant mystery aspect, you’ll love this list of best mystery shows like OA each one is a little different but they’re all great series to binge watch. We hope you enjoy the mysteries that await, we sure did.

The Leftovers

Starring: Justin Theroux, Amy Brenneman, Christopher Eccleston

If you were going through your day and suddenly the people you loved disappeared all at once, how would you react? This addition to our list of series like The OA is about a world just like ours where 2% of the world’s population disappears on the same day. That might not seem like a lot but that’s about 140 million people worldwide. The Leftovers tv show tells the story of the families who’ve been left behind and how they deal with the repercussions. Some try to figure out what happened and some can’t deal with it at all. The HBO series The Leftovers is a mystery show that will have you hooked from the first few minutes of watching it and you’ll stay hooked until the end of the series when you finally understand what has really happened.

back to menu ↑

Stranger Things

Starring: Millie Bobby Brown, Finn Wolfhard, Winona Ryder

Watch on Netflix

If you love science fiction and the 80’s, you’ll love this addition to our list of best mystery series called Stranger Things. The Netflix series Stranger Things is about another disappearance and the horrifying and exhilarating twists and turns that come with it. This story is about a young boy named Will who never came home. His mom is worried sick and no one will listen to her pleas. When other strange things start to happen in their small town, the police chief, Will’s mom and brother, and his friends might be his only hope. In the Stranger Things show, things take an even stranger turn when a young girl with a love for Eggos and telepathic powers turn up. Will the mismatched gang of heroes be able to solve the mystery before it’s too late? Watch Stranger Things tv series to find out.

back to menu ↑


Starring: Terry O’Quinn, Josh Holloway, Evangeline Lilly

The Lost tv show is one of the top mystery shows like The OA on our list. This series is about a group of mismatched people who find themselves stranded on an island after a deadly plane crash. The concept might sound simple enough but the Lost series is much more than Gilligan with guns. This mystery tv series will definitely blow your mind. Lost is hard to explain and it’s best that we don’t give anything away. The main premise of this story is that the survivors are trying to find a way off of the island that they’ve crashed on. This island in the Lost tv series is in the middle of the Pacific and home to a colony of people who live there called the “others”. There’s also something scary in the jungle and a mysterious number that keeps showing up. Watch the Lost pilot to begin your journey with an amazing cast and a story that’s been woven together as if by magic. This show is a mysterious masterpiece that you must watch now.

back to menu ↑


Starring; Jacqueline McKenzie, Joel Gretsch, Patrick John Flueger

The 4400 show is a lot like The Leftovers except it’s in reverse. This alternative to The OA is a fascinating series about the return of 4,400 people who all show up at the same time. When a ball of light comes sailing to Earth, everyone thought destruction would arise, no would could imagine what was about to happen. Familiar faces that have disappeared from different times are back and they haven’t aged a day. In the 4400 tv show, you will follow the dumbfounded federal agents on the case as they slowly discover that the missing people who’ve now returned are a lot different from those who disappeared. This addition to our list of show recommendations is a blend of intrigue, science fiction, and good and bad. Click on the link found here to grab The 4400 complete series, because you won’t want to miss a single episode of this mystery show.

back to menu ↑


Starring: Patrick Brammall, Genevieve O’Reilly, Emma Booth

The Glitch Netflix series is another one of the top show suggestions that must be included on our list of shows like The OA. Like the 4400, the Glitch tv series is also a story about people who are back, except that the people in this story are back from the dead. Six people have risen from their graves and no one can explain why or how. They aren’t zombies, but they aren’t normal either. The townspeople have been turned upside down and the returned have no memory of their past. James, a local policeman, is called to uncover the truth but this won’t be easy since this has never happened before. This Australian tv series is clever and refreshing and each of the Glitch episodes will tell you a little more. If you want to watch a mysterious show that will leave you scoffing in disbelief, start watching Glitch now.

back to menu ↑

Zero Hour

Starring: Scott Michael Foster, Anthony Edwards, Carmen Ejogo

Watch on Amazon

Zero Hour was a short lived series that only lasted for one season but that doesn’t mean that it wasn’t great. The Zero Hour tv series should never have been given the boot. This OA alternative is a mystery thriller that used history and logic in a way that was considered too intelligent for some. The Zero Hour tv show is about fate and one of the biggest conspiracies in human history. In this series, you will follow a man who spent 20 years of his life working for a paranormal skeptic’s magazine. He never believed in anything that didn’t have scientific proof, but when his wife is abducted, he starts to have an open mind. Zero Hour is a non stop thrill ride about the hunt for the ultimate relic and the conspiracies that have covered it up for generations. If you love conspiracies, history, and action packed scenes, give this old tv series a try, you won’t be disappointed.

back to menu ↑


Starring: Adeel Akhtar, Paul Higgins, Neil Maskell

The last addition to our list of shows similar to The OA has to be Utopia. The Utopia tv series centers around a graphic novel and a group of people who meet online. In this mystery tv series, the bizarre book is rumored to have predicted the worst disasters in human history and it’s the key to understanding more about the future. The group of online friends are trying to understand more about the book but doing so will be a challenge because a shadowy organization of killers known only as “The Network” wants to get their hands on the graphic novel in question. This sci-fi, mystery thriller reveals a little more with each of the Utopia episodes and the dark and comical aspects of Utopia make it well worth the watch. If you’re looking for something mysterious to watch that has a unique visual style and a superb cast, start watching Utopia now. You haven’t seen a series this good in a very long time.

More Movies Like